Accomplished mystery author Caroline Taylor has taken a bold step into the realm of mainstream fiction with her latest novel, Tough Love. Rooted in personal experience and inspired by a life-threatening medical crisis involving her husband, Taylor’s novel delves into themes of family dysfunction, loss, and human resilience. In this interview, Taylor discusses the inspirations behind her work, the challenges of venturing beyond mystery, and the creative journey that brought Tough Love to life.
Reflecting on the inspiration behind Tough Love, Taylor reveals the deeply personal foundation of her story: a frightening medical emergency that raised questions about the future and mortality. “Those thoughts—how would a grieving widow get on with life?—inspired my first attempt at mainstream fiction,” she shares. Although her husband survived, the experience underscored the vulnerability of life, setting the stage for a narrative rich in emotional complexity.
Tough Love tackles themes of loss, economic instability, and family struggles—issues that resonate with readers on a deeply personal level. Taylor’s own life experiences have shaped these themes, imbuing the story with authenticity. She explains, “Someone once told me that people nowadays think death is optional. I’ve learned it isn’t true. I think we also tend to expect that the good life we’ve all worked so hard to maintain cannot be disrupted by events beyond our control.” This perspective, combined with Taylor’s candid observations on family and relationship dynamics, brings a raw truth to Tough Love, inviting readers to confront life’s unpredictability.
In developing her protagonist, Lilac, Taylor embraced the complexity of human emotions and moral dilemmas. Lilac, struggling with loneliness, grief, and self-doubt, faces a series of challenges that test her resolve. Taylor describes her character’s inner conflict: “Lilac is lonely, grieving, judgmental, and, to her way of thinking, cowardly.” From an estranged half-sister with a troubled child to an attraction to her married neighbor, Lilac’s journey is as much about personal growth as it is about navigating difficult decisions. These layered relationships and moral struggles make Tough Love a resonant exploration of character and choice.
A seasoned writer of mysteries, Taylor admits that Tough Love required a different approach, especially in structuring the story. “In mysteries, the protagonist confronts the antagonist after a search for the truth that involves many roadblocks and scary scenes,” she explains. “But the tangle of relationships in Tough Love posed an entirely different challenge.” By focusing on the protagonist’s transformation rather than solving a crime, Taylor faced the unique challenge of weaving together complex family relationships, personal boundaries, and emotional vulnerability.
Taylor’s diverse background in the Foreign Service has broadened her perspective, which she brings to her writing. “There’s a big, wide world out there where people live vastly different lives and hold widely different worldviews,” she reflects. This understanding of diverse experiences informs her characters, adding depth to their personal and cultural nuances. Her travels and professional experiences add layers to her storytelling, often influencing the characters and scenarios in her works.
Asked what she hopes readers gain from Tough Love, Taylor’s response is straightforward yet profound. “Treasure your loved ones,” she advises. “Surround yourself with people who matter to you. When things don’t work out as you hope, that’s life. Don’t be too quick to judge others when you don’t know all the facts.” This message reflects the heart of Tough Love: a reminder of life’s fragility and the importance of compassion and resilience.
Among the novel’s memorable characters, Taylor found particular enjoyment in writing Mavis Hennessy and Grover Somerset. “Mavis has some valuable insights that help Lilac see her situation from a different perspective,” she says, highlighting the importance of secondary characters in supporting Lilac’s journey. For Taylor, the dance scenes between Mavis and Grover offered a “fun way to show Lilac’s leap into the unknown,” a glimpse of the transformative power of new experiences and friendships.
When it comes to the creative process, Taylor identifies herself as a “pantser”—someone who lets the story unfold naturally rather than sticking to an outline. “I have tried to plot my novels in advance, but they wind up looking hackneyed and derivative,” she admits. By allowing the characters to guide her, Taylor maintains an authentic and organic flow to her storytelling.
As for what’s on the horizon, Taylor hints at the possibility of further exploring mainstream fiction while keeping her roots in mystery alive. With three mystery-thrillers currently in development, she’s eager to see how readers respond to Tough Love before embarking on another mainstream project.
Taylor’s journey from mystery to mainstream fiction with Tough Love reflects her courage in exploring new storytelling landscapes. Her narrative weaves together complex themes of family, love, and resilience, delivering a story that speaks to the heart of life’s challenges. For readers looking to connect with characters facing real-world dilemmas, Tough Love promises a poignant, thought-provoking experience.
Download Tough Love Today!
